In the first two parts of this series, we discussed micromanagement as a leading cause of problems once a business grows beyond the capacity of one person to juggle all the issues an expanding business encounters, and why it is necessary to remind owners of why they are in business so they can stay motivated to make changes in management style to succeed and attain their personal goals. In addition, the first practical tools were outlined: The Business Plan and the Organization Chart. In this article, we will discuss Job Descriptions, what a good Job Description entails, why they are necessary, and how they relate to the Organization Chart and Business Plan.
Job Descriptions – Not your newspaper’s (or online) JD anymore…
Laymen and many business people view Job Descriptions as a pain, a formality, and just something to dash off to throw online or in the paper to get applicants for an opening in their business. Not so! Let me repeat… NOT SO!
A proper and effective Job Description serves a variety of purposes.
First, it serves as the basis for that job posting in the paper or online. But before that happens, a lot of thought has to go into the process of the potential hire. Why are you hiring for this slot? What are the qualifications needed to perform well? What are the personal attributes necessary to fit into the organization? Are there physical or mentation requirements or limitations to be considered? Language? Ability to read and write well? Speak well? Language skills? The list can be extensive, and it must be comprehensive.
If an owner feels that they just need a ‘warm body’ to fill a position, my suggestion is they stop being a business owner and do something else for a living. It is unfair to both the company and the person hired to be a bad fit. The hire is a person with a life, and not hiring the right person and taking care in the process simply sets them – and the company – up for failure, and failure is expensive and wasteful and can be devastating for the person so abused, and it is abuse to intentionally hire someone to fail.
Second, a good Job Description describes the position in detail. That means listing all the duties the position requires, not some vague phrases that sound good and mean little. Saying that you need a “good administrator” means absolutely nothing. Saying you require someone to “manage office staff, ensure bills are paid on schedule, assist with cash flow planning, negotiate with vendors for office purchases” and so on is specific, and will clarify both to the owner and the applicant what the job will be like and what will be expected.
Third, a Job Description identifies by title and/or function, who reports to whom. It is an impossible task for employees to perform effectively if they do not have a clear undestanding who their real boss is, or who reports to them. Too many companies and organizations get into trouble by acting like ‘puppies in a basket,’ where everyone does everything, and they get into that habit when really small. As they grow, they don’t know how to get out of that mess. Remember the Organization Chart I said was so necessary? Well, here is where that chart is applied in the real world. By mapping out the functions of the company and who reports to whom on an Org Chart, and referring to it every time a hire is contemplated, it becomes very clear where that new person will fit and what they should and will be doing. Without that Org Chart, every hire is a new experience, overlapping duties and authorities sprout like weeds, and your organization becomes a dis-organization very quickly. The Org Chart is a tool to keep that from happening.
Fourth, a thorough Job Description will identify the working conditions the person will work in. Will they be working in an office, an unheated shop, around dangerous or loud equipment, outside, dirty, smelly? You and the applicant need to know and think it through to make a good fit. In addition, what are the physical requirements? Lifting, climbing, sitting all day, crawling, repeated arm and hand movements, bright or dim lighting… all can be restrictions for applicants. Again, it is important to know up front before hiring or an applicant accepting the position.
Fifth and finally, a good Job Description needs to set out very specific and measureable metrics for the position that are designed to fit into the company’s financial plan (remember that Business Plan I mentioned in another article?). How many widgits an hour, deadlines, paperwork required, reports to monitor performance, allowable waste of materials, cleanliness, dress, safety issues… all need to be quantified (numbers, hours, days, percentages, parameters) and listed. This forces the owner or manager to think the position through with an eye towards the company’s needs as it relates to both company culture and the needs of the company. It also gives the applicant and ultimately the person hired a very specific knowledge of what will be expected of them for the compensation offered. Too many times, we are left totally in the dark as to what our job really is or what is expected of us. Then, when we are evaluated down the road, we have no idea what we are really being evaluated on! Again, a recipe for failure, resentment, unrealized expectations, and morale problems on both sides of the equation. Besides, it’s just plain unfair!
Personally, I ask an applicant to read through this sort of extensive Job Description right at the top of the interview, and use it to talk about the position in detail. That way, if the applicant has any concerns about being able to do the work, it comes out right away. Finding that out later is a waste of everyone’s time and company resources.
I cannot emphasize this enough… you need a good Business Plan and a detailed financial plan to do this right. You need to know how each person in the organization will contribute to that plan in order for the plan to succeed. If you expect to have, say, a 10% Net Profit at the end of the year, you will have to deconstruct how to get there. How many widgits and what price and at what cost, what the overhead is, and so forth. If you have 10 people making widgits, how many per day or week will it take to get there? Are 10 people enough or too many? How many managers, designers, administrators, etc? This will then determine what you can pay them, what the level of benefits you can afford, and so on. Dovetailing the Job Descriptions into this plan is good planning.
What’s the old saying? If you fail to plan, plan to fail.
Please contact me offline at [email protected] with anycomments, suggestions or ideas for future articles that you may not want to share here.