All you really want is a home you can live in comfortably, have the family over, let the grandkids run through, well there are people out there who don’t want you to have it.  At least not at the same price they can outbid you for, but they will gladly sell it to you after they have done all the cosmetic work to hopefully cover up the flaws.  It is a shark tank out there, a big shark tank. 

I have been looking for a home to buy for the past two months.  We have looked at quite a few places and have found out there is no rhyme or reason to the pricing.  The Real Estate agents will tell you, “it is just the going price of the day” or “the market is coming back so grab one now” what ever happened to a good old fashioned true appraisal?  What I have found out is no one learned a lesson from the mortgage meltdown.  Not the banks, the loan agents, nor the Real Estate professionals.  In fact the only ones who might have learned a lesson is the title companies but their involvement is at the back end of the process and to my knowledge they never caused the mortgage problems.

 

So, what happens in the buying process now?  Well, for one thing, never count on the actual list price especially if it is a short sale or a foreclosure.  The banks have absolutely no intention of actually selling that home at that price.  Let me give you an example.  We looked at a home and there was quite a bit of interest.  They listed the home for $123,000.  A decent home, not in the best neighborhood but in an area where homes are being bought at a price people can afford.  This home needed little work except for a wall in the living room.  A previous owner had bricked in one wall in the living room in order to install a free standing fireplace.  Yes they mortared the brick onto the existing wall and yes, the wall was splitting from the weight.  No problem though that could be easily fixed, we have a friend who is a contractor.  The rest of the home was really pretty nice.  There were a lot of people going through and in retrospect I now can tell who the investors were.  “Oh look at that wall, I would sure not buy this house”.  “Oh that tile is disgusting”.  “Oh that back yard is no where near big enough”.  Uh huh sure, you were probably one of the people who bid it up so real people with real families could not afford it and that is the catch. 

See while they listed it at $123,000 the bank had no intention of actually selling it for that price.  And people who have been in the market for awhile know this and bid accordingly.  Of course our Realtor should have known and warned us but that is another story.  Needless to say our measly bid of $125k was not accepted.  Ok by me I would really have preferred a home on another street in that subdivision.  So onward we search.

Then we looked at another place, good bones but needed a great deal of work in order for me to live in it.  We had seen another home in the same neighborhood that sold for $155k in immaculate condition and even one that was in the same shape as this one go for $129k so we were going to bid $135k right in the middle kind of.  There were 10 bids and all over asking price on that house.  Again it was not move in ready so investors were looking for a flip or a rental property.  Out bid again but this lady is not giving up, no sirree bob. 

We bid last week on another condo.  Asking price $82.4k and yes we learned our lesson so we went in with $92k.  Then a couple days later the bank came back and asked for everyone’s BEST bid.  Huh?  They did not counter anything but wanted best bids anyway?  Well we did because we really like this unit and offered $95k going in and we will see where it goes. 

But I have learned, we are still looking and have already found another townhouse in a better town so we will be bidding on that townhouse.  It is a Fannie/Freddie home and the skinny is that they prefer families or owner occupied on their foreclosures.  So yes, we will bid over their asking price of $164k because it is well worth it (1400 sq ft and ready to move in) but now we are in another conundrum.  Do we go in way over and hope ours is selected?  Do we go in a little bit over and not look like greedy investor types?  What exactly do you do with a seller who wants to sell to families?  Well, we will somehow go in with a bid that is not outrageous but solid and we will include a buyer letter.  We are very familiar with this particular part of town and have looked there for months trying to find a place.  So we will tell them that.  We will tell them how perfect that home will be for us and we will wait. 

In the meantime, while we are waiting, what do you think we will be doing?  That’s right, we will be looking for another home.  Because, THAT is the reality about home buying these days.  One out of 10 that come on the market are actual straight seller sales(and that is a generous guess).  And the banks are still trying to recover all of their money.  As far as the insurance paid by the Private Mortgage Co/AIG I am not aware of what they are doing in regard to any claims they had to pay out either.  You never know on any house you bid on whether or not the bank received PMI insurance reimbursement so they very well could be making a profit on any given home.  In fact most homes could be in that category.  The GSE’s are now forcing the banks to buy back on the loans they can prove were fraudulent so who knows what a house’s history really is and that is just how the banks want it. 

In fact beware of the bank who wants to use their Title Company.  You could very well end up with a robo-signed title search.  After all when all the business is done, a title company you or I have never heard of could very well vanish just like mortgage brokers did back in 2008.  And when that happens, the buyer could be left with a mortgage on a house where they do not hold clear title.  In fact homes sold since the mortgage meltdown business could very well run into trouble when they try to re-sale and it would take hundreds, maybe thousands of them prior to people even becoming aware of a problem.  That is fact but also based on my total mistrust of banks these days and a clear understanding of the mess they have at Mortgage Electronic Registration Service( MERS) who was supposed to be keeping the docs on loans that were sliced and diced.  Problem is now they cannot exactly match docs to original loans, big problem – huge.  So what is the best way to fix it?  Lie your ass off again, plain and simple.

So, if you have not guessed yet the business of buying a home is not for the faint of heart or for the novice without a real good realtor.  I am lucky my sister-in-law is an escrow officer, a loan officer and has her real estate license.  She is not active in the business anymore but she knows a great deal after 25 years in the business.  But the market has changed and not for the better.  Even in the heady days of multiple bids and ever increasing home prices you still had a buyer and a seller on somewhat equal terms.  And an offer was taken, usually as soon as you had looked at the house. I put together my offer and my RE person would present to the other realtor, then we would either dicker a bit or just accept the offer.  There was not a great deal of mistrust, in fact making an offer for the asking price a lot of times was just what a seller expected.

It was not until the Bush administration, the banks, mortgage companies and realtors dreamed up these new processes that things changed and not for the better.  It all came crashing down on them and instead of learning their lessons, they are still trying to screw the consumer.  THEN they wonder why they are so hated.  When I close on my home, I am sure going to let them know…to be continued.

36
Leave a Comment

Please Login to comment
5 Comment threads
31 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
7 Comment authors
bitoAdLibSpirit42SueInCachoicelady Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
coveark
Member
coveark

In many cases I do feel bad for those whose home values dropped……But…………those who had bought in an earlier time and then were very excited when the bubble happened….. ( say they bought a home for $89,000 and in the bubble years they were told it was worth $650,000) Well, that was dream cash and unless they sold….it was never real.

My friend lost over $1,000,000. in the stock market during the big loss time in tech. stocks…..It was awful for some time and then she told me…….We had that much on paper from our investments. We never invested nearly that much and we never saw the money at all…..It was our financial joy but it was never real.

Those are the things we always need to be aware of. Good luck on your search…….

Now I am in a pickle trying to sell a very nice home out of CA and will get home no matter how I have to live…..I am adaptable and frankly am not spoiled so I will make it done. I hope that we all are………not you and me but our people. That our wisdom and strength grows for the betterment of us all

Report this comment

bito
Member

coveark, Correct me if I am in error, but the did not the example of the 89,000/650,000 home also add to the false financial economy? Many homeowners were doing refinancing and taking out the equity of their homes further fueling the housing bubble? I realize that some amount of capturing of the equity, from one’s home, was good for the hard economy if the money was spent on actual products and or remodeling, however too often it wasn’t.

Report this comment

coveark
Member
coveark

I would think so. I, personally would just look around and think ….this is insane. It was unsustainable and I am quite sure that in the long run our money would be worthless.

It gave a real windfall to those who took the money out but if the result was losing their home……..was it worth it in the end?

It was an excellent time for my Son in Law who is a contractor. When times are very very good people tend to live up to their income and and when the fall comes it is not so pretty. It was a false very very good time.

I do not know all the answers at all. I just thought it was crazy and that only came from years of experience…..both good and bad.:-)

Report this comment

Spirit42
Member
Spirit42

Your words are harsh and judgmental of a lot of Real Estate Professionals who are out there doing a great job. I am one of them.

It really seems to me you may have a bad agent and one rotten apple does not always spoil the entire barrel as you infer above.

I see your points on what has happened to you and I’m sure your stories are real but if you had an agent who explained the process of short sales and foreclosures, you would have been better equipped to deal with the process.

I doubt your numbers that 1 in 10 sales are traditional transactions. Where did you get the data?

I speak from the experience of selling dozens of homes successfully over these past few years and my buyers are very satisfied with how I educated them and communicated with them on the process. They have all secured homes that have since increased in value because we did our homework going in. This can happen for you too.

It would seem that your case of sour grapes would be resolved if you’d fire that agent and go with one who has a proven track record of success.

Check references and be sure you like this person and can have them manage your transaction as they teach you the real ins and outs of navigating the short sale and foreclosure marketplace.

And make sure they understand the process and can explain it to you before you hire them.

Report this comment

AdLib
Admin

Spirit42, welcome to The Planet!

I would disagree with your comment, I think that everyone must be willing to accept criticism of their industry and profession without taking it personally. It is no reflection on you nor on other professionals in the Real Estate profession to criticize the current process in dealing with foreclosures.

The way I read it, Sue’s article focuses on the new practices of the banks in handling foreclosures and on the high level of speculators in the marketplace.

I’m interested in your take on this from a real estate agent’s POV, do you see the banks’ current handling of foreclosure sales generally the same as before the 2008 crash or do you see it as having changed? Is there a greater percent of speculators buying foreclosures today than owner-occupiers?

BTW, SueInCA is a financial professional with years of experience in the banking industry, so for me, her insights on the evolution of banking and lending practices are meaningful.

Lastly, I would just suggest that in the pursuit of steering clear of harsh and judgmental words, it would be consistent not to apply descriptions of others’ experiences and POVs as “sour grapes”.

At The Planet we welcome everyone’s POVs and disagreements, we believe that it’s healthy to have honest discussion and debate and most constructive to do so with a modicum of respect for all members.

Report this comment

Spirit42
Member
Spirit42

I see a vast change in how the banks handle the short sale and foreclosure process. It’s far better than before and actually works in a reasonable time.

The process can turn into bidding with other buyers and even when you have the high bid, if your in competition, they will ask for best and final. When an agent and a buyer are confident that theirs is the high bid, its not necessary to increase it. We have let many am offer stand at best and final and we got accepted.

We have completed literally dozens of these sales and all it takes is one: educate the buyer and two: communicate with them a lot.

I know there is some sort of family connection with Sue and her agent yet something just does not ring true to my experience.

Report this comment

AdLib
Admin

Spirit42, are you seeing speculators outweighing those who are buying homes for themselves?

This type of thing was part of the destructive cycle that culminated in 2008’s crash. When homes are being bought more by speculators to quickly flip and sell at higher prices, that process has repeatedly led to a cycle of over-inflation of prices which is eventually followed by a crash when the “pyramid scheme” can’t be sustained.

Of course, add to that the subprime loans and Wall Street derivative sales of them globally and we had a massive collapse. But in the early to mid 1990’s, we had another real estate bubble burst for the same speculation-cycle reason, homes becoming far over valued due to the frequent flipping.

I’m not saying that people shouldn’t be investing in real estate but the feeding frenzy of quick flipping homes has had disastrous results again and again.

Report this comment

kesmarn
Admin

I know that Sue is totally capable of speaking for herself, but I would just note that in the “mini-bio” attached to her article, she explains that she has had 24 years of experience in the banking and financial industries. She was a fraud investigator for much of that time. Her sister-in-law is a loan officer, an escrow officer and has her real estate license.

If a knowledgeable team like that has encountered ethically shabby behavior, I don’t think I’d chalk it up entirely to “sour grapes.”

Report this comment

Spirit42
Member
Spirit42

But you are doing the same thing in your comment saying there is a near total breakdown in business. You both are lumping a lot of pros into one bad barrel and you missed the point of what I said entirely.

So I think it would be nice if she spoke for herself and maybe answered some of my concerns and questions. It seems you have failed to do that in speaking for her.

btw-
I did read her bio when I read the post and I stand by my comment.

Report this comment

kesmarn
Admin

I don’t think either Sue or I said that every realtor in the entire country is corrupt…which would be a ridiculous statement to make. So obviously I’m not going to defend a phony “position” that neither she nor I hold.

When employers short-pay employees, when banks use little tricks to try to get customers to incur late fees, when medical suppliers bill Medicare fraudulently, when companies hire union-busters and lobbyists to write legislation that harms consumers, when energy companies pollute ground water and our shorelines, it doesn’t seem to be an exaggeration to say that there’s been a breakdown in trust between the consumer and business.

And — no — I didn’t just say that all business is always bad all the time.

Report this comment

kesmarn
Admin

I’ve never known you to pigeon-hole or stereotype any group before, Sue. And I didn’t think you were about to start now!

😀

Report this comment

Spirit42
Member
Spirit42

You said :I think it’s in part because this is a story of yet one more instance of the nearly complete breakdown of trust in American business. The atmosphere seems so predatory. ”

She said: “The Real Estate agents will tell you, “it is just the going price of the day” or “the market is coming back so grab one now” what ever happened to a good old fashioned true appraisal? What I have found out is no one learned a lesson from the mortgage meltdown. Not the banks, the loan agents, nor the Real Estate professionals. In fact the only ones who might have learned a lesson is the title companies but their involvement is at the back end of the process and to my knowledge they never caused the mortgage problems.”

So I say that we DID learn our lessons and she is saying we did not. What she means to say is maybe some are not that bright?

Report this comment

kesmarn
Admin

That’s a great FDR quote, b’ito. Thanks!

Report this comment

kesmarn
Admin

Sometimes Wikipedia comes in handy:

A straw man is a type of argument and is an informal fallacy based on misrepresentation of an opponent’s position.[1] To “attack a straw man” is to create the illusion of having refuted a proposition by replacing it with a superficially similar yet unequivalent proposition (the “straw man”), and refuting it, without ever having actually refuted the original position.

Report this comment

bito
Member

Practices of the unscrupulous money changers stand indicted in the court of public opinion, rejected by the hearts and minds of men.
True they have tried, but their efforts have been cast in the pattern of an outworn tradition. Faced by failure of credit they have proposed only the lending of more money. Stripped of the lure of profit by which to induce our people to follow their false leadership, they have resorted to exhortations, pleading tearfully for restored confidence. They know only the rules of a generation of self-seekers. They have no vision, and when there is no vision the people perish.

FDR

Report this comment

choicelady
Member

Oh wow – the very idea that people play these games with would-be homeowners is disgusting! It is my profound belief that mortgage insurance has a role here – the banks get a lot of the loan covered in a default, put up a house on a “loss leader” price then play the game of upward spirals that drive out actual live-in owners but help the flipper and landlord. Since none of this is illegal, there is little to be done.

Sue – we wish you well on the condo purchase! A HOME is different from a HOUSE, and you have the right to a HOME! CA started this downward spiral (death spiral?) of housing as investment not as residence back in the early 70s, and we’ve not seen the end. Good luck bucking the trend!

Report this comment

kesmarn
Admin

Oh Sue, what a narrative of total frustration! I’m not entirely sure why, but there’s something about the whole situation that inspires a reaction of something like trepidation in me.

I think it’s in part because this is a story of yet one more instance of the nearly complete breakdown of trust in American business. The atmosphere seems so predatory.

As you said there was once a time when the buyer’s realtor and the seller’s realtor got together and worked out a reasonable deal. What happened?! I’m pretty naive when it comes to buying property, but my understanding has always been that the asking price was usually considered to be on the high side and the buyer was likely to offer something lower than the list price. Then the bargaining would commence. Apparently that is all wrong in the 21st century? Now the buyer has to offer something between the asking price and infinity. How does anyone decide?

My son once took a course in Business Ethics. Do those two words still go together? Or are we in the land of oxymoron now?

BFF, I’ll be interested in hearing the rest of the story on this one. Please keep us posted.

Report this comment

coveark
Member
coveark

OMG !!!!! That is exactly why I left CA. !!!!!

Everytime I agreed to buy a place (2001) some mysterious phantom out of the blue would show up and make a higher offer ………….I just figured it was a back stabbing realtor. I guess that was true but there was more involved !!! ( and I had cash )

Pardon me while I go vomit!!!( this Bullshit makes me sick )

Thank you for this article. Oh God, I have to puke again………..I just got back from CA last night and want to go back but am now better informed.

Report this comment