• RSS
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
SueInCa On April - 1 - 2013

mirabalstamp
Last weekend I was looking for something interesting to watch on TV and came across the MGM channel.  As I was looking through their line-up I saw a few movies that looked interesting so I watched one and set the other for recording.  The one I watched was: In The Time of The Butterflies, starring Selma Hayek and Edward James Olmos.  What an incredibly interesting movie it was too.  The movie was a dramatization of the lives of the Mirabal sisters growing up in Dominican Republic.  As the movie ended, the credits recapped the results of what had taken place in the movie and I realized I was watching something that really did happen, dramatized or not so I decided to look into the history of the movement and The Dominican Republic.  After all, these days a vacation in the Dominican Republic is very normal.

The Hermanas Mirabal(as they are referred to) were four Dominican political dissidents who opposed the dictatorship of Rafael Trujillo.  They called themselves Las Mariposas (the butterflies) because that was the name Minerva Mirabal gave to herself in her underground activities.  On November 25, 1960, three of the sisters were assassinated returning home from a visit with their husbands who were in prison.

museum

The Mirabals were farmers in the Dominican Republic.  The sisters grew up in a relatively upper-class, cultured environment and married and raised families, however, influenced by her uncle, Minerva became involved in the political movement against Rafael Trujillo.  Trujillo had been the president of the country from 1930 to 1938 and from 1942 to 1952, and afterwards, became its dictator. In the 30 years of his reign, it is estimated that 30,000 people were tortured and killed, that averages to 1,000 per year and if he killed that many people, I would assume he was an acting dictator for most of that time.  Minerva studied law but was not allowed to practice as it was against the law for women to study law.  It is said that Trujillo, because of his interest in her, allowed her to study.  However when it came time to graduate, she was not even allowed the diploma that was her due because she had scorned Trujillo’s attempts at romance. Her sisters followed her into the political movement, first Maria Teresa, who joined after staying with Minerva and learning about their activities, and then Patria, who joined after witnessing a massacre by some of Trujillo’s men while on a religious retreat. Dedé joined later, due to having been held back by her husband Jaimito. They eventually formed a group called the Movement of the Fourteenth of June (named after the date of the massacre Patria witnessed), to oppose the Trujillo regime. They distributed pamphlets about the many people Trujillo had killed, and obtained materials for guns and bombs to use when they finally openly revolted. Within the group, the Mirabels called themselves Las Mariposas (The Butterflies), after Minerva’s underground name.  The butterfly also became a symbol to indicate like-minded citizens against Trujillo. (The picture above is the home the women lived in for the last 10 months of their lives and is now a Museum)

Two of the sisters, Minerva and Maria Teresa, were incarcerated and tortured on different occasions. Three of the sisters’ husbands were incarcerated at La Victoria Penitentiary in Santo Domingo as a result of their dissident activities.  Despite these setbacks, they persisted in fighting to end Trujillo’s leadership.  In 1960, the Organization of American States condemned Trujillo’s actions and sent observers to the Dominican Republic. Minerva and Maria Teresa were freed, but their husbands remained in prison.  On their remembrance website, Learn to Question, the author writes, “No matter how many times Trujillo jailed them, no matter how much of their property and possessions he seized, Minerva, Patria and Maria Teresa refused to give up on their mission to restore democracy and civil liberties to the island nation.”  The OAS has repeatedly opposed unilateral intervention in the affairs of member countries. However, the OAS did approve (1965) the U.S. intervention in the Dominican Republic’s civil war, 5 years after the deaths of the Mirabal sisters.

On November 25, 1960, three of the sisters, Patria, Minerva, and Maria Teresa, and driver Rufino de la Cruz, were visiting Patria and Minerva’s incarcerated husbands.  On the way home, they were stopped by Trujillo’s henchmen and the sisters and their driver were separated and all were clubbed to death.  The bodies were then gathered and put into their Jeep which was run off the mountain to make it look like an accident.

After Trujillo was assassinated in May 1961, General Pupo Roman admitted to have personal knowledge that the sisters were killed by two men, Victor Alicinio and Peña Rivera, who were Trujillo’s right hand men. Ciriaco de la Rosa, Ramon Emilio Rojas, Alfonso Cruz Vlaeria and Emilio Estrada Malleta were all members of his secret police force. The question of whether Trujiollo ordered the secret police or whether they acted on their own is unconfirmed. Virgilio Pina Chevalier (Don Cucho), Trujillo’s family member and intimate collaborator, wrote in his 2008 book, La era de Trujillo. Narraciones de Don Cucho, that Trujillo referred to the Mirabal assassinations as being far from anything to do with him. “But we know orders of this nature could not come from any authority lower than national sovereignty. That national sovereignty was none other than Trujillo himself however it is a possibility it could have taken place without his consent.  In light of the fact none were prosecuted, I would suggest that was a highly unlikely scenario.  After the the assassination of Trujillo, the Dominican Republic was engaged in civil wars.  U.S. President Lyndon Johnson, convinced of the defeat of the Loyalist forces by the Rebel forces and fearing “a second Cuba” on America’s doorstep, ordered U.S. forces to restore order. The decision to intervene militarily in the Dominican Republic was Lyndon Johnson’s personal decision. All civilian advisers had recommended against immediate intervention hoping that the(Junta) Loyalist side could bring an end to the civil war.

President Johnson took the advice of his Ambassador in Santo Domingo, W. Tapley Bennett, who pointed out the inefficiency and indecisiveness of the Dominican military leaders. Bennett suggested that the US interpose its forces between the rebels and those of the junta, thereby effecting a cease-fire. The United States could then ask the Organization of American States to negotiate a political settlement between the opposing factions.

Chief of Staff General Wheeler told CINCLANT General Palmer that “Your unannounced mission is to prevent the Dominican Republic from going Communist.” Citing as an official reason for the invasion the need to protect the lives of foreigners, none of whom had been killed or wounded, a fleet of 41 vessels was sent to blockade the island, and an invasion was launched by the Marines and parts of the Army”s 82nd Airbourne Division.  Aproximateley 75 members of E company of the 7th Special Forces Group were also deployed. Ultimately, 42,000 soldiers and marines were ordered to the Dominican Republic. The United States along with the Organization of American States formed an inter-American military force to assist in intervention in the Dominican Republic.  The invasion was, of course, resisted however a cease-fire was negotiated fairly quickly.

On May 5 the Act of Santo Domingo was signed by Colonel Benoit (Loyalist), Colonel Caamano (Constitutionalist) and the OAS Special Committee. The Act provided for a general cease-fire, recognition of the International Security Zone, agreement to assist relief agencies, and the sanctity of diplomatic missions. The Act set the framework for later negotiations but failed to stop all of the fighting. Constitutionalist snipers continued to shoot at US forces, however, major fire fights between the Dominican factions did subside for a time.

Denied a military victory, the Constitutionalist rebels quickly had a Constitutionalist congress elect Caamaño president of the country. US officials countered by backing General Imbert. On May 7, Imbert was sworn in as president of the Government of National Reconstruction. The next step in the stabilization process, as envisioned by Washington and the OAS, was to arrange an agreement between President Caamaño and President Imbert to form a provisional government committed to early elections. However, Caamaño refused to meet with Imbert until several of the Loyalist officers, including Wessin y Wessin, were made to leave the country.

On 13 May General Imbert began Operation LIMPIEZA (Cleanup) and his forces were successful in eliminating pockets of rebel resistance outside Ciudad Nueva and silencing Radio Santo Domingo. Operation CLEANUP ended on 21 May.

By May 14 the Americans, in establishing a “safety corridor” connecting the San Isidro Air Base and the “Duarte” Bridge to the Embajador Hotel and United States Embassy in the center of Santo Domingo, had essentially sealed-off the Constitutionalist area of Santo Domingo. Road blocks were established and patrols ran continuously. Some 6,500 people from many nations were evacuated to safety. In addition, the US forces airlifted in large relief supplies for Dominican nationals.  So you can see the fighting went on for several years after the Mirabal sisters and Trujillo were assassinated.  There has been trouble in the Dominican Republic throughout its history but there has been a relative peace established for the past 40 plus years, with some missteps along the way but no truly secure government because of the different leaders who have been elected, but they have managed to keep a relative peace within the country.

originalhome

Dedé Mirabal, who did not accompany her sisters on the trip, has lived to tell the stories of the death of her sisters. (the picture to the right is the original family home where Dede’ Mirabal lives today) As of 2012, Dedé lives in Salcedo in the house where the sisters were born. She works to preserve her sisters’ memory through the Museo Hermanas Mirabal which is also located in Salcedo and was home to the women for the final ten months of their lives. She published a book, Vivas en su Jardín, on August 25, 2009.

On December 17, 1999, the United Nations General Assembly designated November 25 as the annual date of the International Day for the Elimination of Violence Agansit Women in commemoration of the sisters.  The day also marks the beginning of a 16-day period of Activism against Gender Violence.  December 10, which is the end of the 16 days, is noted as International Human Rights day.  Also on November 21, 2007, the Salcedo Province was renamed Hermanas Mirabal Province.  The sisters have also been commemorated by their appearance on the 200 Dominican Pesos bill.

The story of the Mirabal sisters has been told in books and in films.

In 1994, Dominican-American author Julia Alvarez published her novel In The Time of Of The Butterflies, a fictionalized account of the lives of the Mirabal sisters.  The novel was adopted into a movie of the same name starring Selma Hayek as Minerva and Edward James Olmos as Trujillo.

Chilean filmmaker Cecilia Domeyko produced Code Name: Butterflies, a documentary that tells the real-life story of the Mirabal sisters. It contains interviews with Dedé Mirabal, and other Dominican members of the Mirabal family.

Actress Michelle Rodriguez co-produced the film Tropico de Sangre which recounts the lives of the sisters. She also stars in the film as Minerva. Dedé Mirabal also participated in the development of the film.

The eventual assassination of Trujillo is portrayed in The Feast of the Goat, a novel published by Mario Vargas Llosa and it portrays its effect on the lives of Dominicians. It refers often to the Mirabal sisters.

I found the movie fascinating and when I realized it was, in part, true, I decided to read up on the history of the country.  It is a fascinating read which I had never undertaken before.  I know about the Dominican Republic and it’s border with Haiti, however only understood it was a Latin country, a provider of excellent baseball players and a great vacation spot.  It is far far more than just a Latin country and I highly recommend reading some of the materials cited to learn more, if you are so inclined.

http://www.learntoquestion.com/seevak/groups/2000/sites/mirabal/mainpage.html

 

Written by SueInCa

I am a soon to be 59 Nana to Anthony who is 11. I live in Benicia CA with my husband and Shih Tsu. I worked in Banking and the Financial Industry for 24 years in Fraud, Risk Management, Account Management, Program Management, Project Management and Customer Service. I was a Fraud Investigator for Credit Card and Merchant Business and investigated internal fraud and responded to Bank robberies. I was also management in most of these positions. Now I am content to find a part time job where I am just a worker bee, no more corporate BS for this gal. I also make jewelry. I can spend hours in a bead shop just touching all the fine baubles. Only another beader would understand that one.

12 Responses so far.

Click here to leave a comment
  1. foodchain says:

    Sue, thanks for doing this. There are so many things to read that I kinda know something about so I tend to let them linger. But this was so intriguing and, as a women’s rights activist in my time, I found it a sad and important reminder. While we all know how horribly women suffer in poorer countries, we don’t hear about their heroines.

  2. foodchain says:

    Sue, I dont’ seem to have trouble having opinions but I have had trouble finding the time to read--much as I need and want to. This article is on my save list for tomorrow or later tonight.

    • SueInCa says:

      No problem Food, as long as you find the time to read it, that is all I want. I wrote this because I, too am a big women;s rights person and I am always so in awe of people who put their life on the line for their beliefs.

  3. kesmarn says:

    What a fascinating story, BFF. I was away from home yesterday, but now I’m glad I’m home and I’ve had a chance to read this amazing article.

    I have to admit that I knew of Trujillo, but did not know the details of the Mirabel sisters’ story. I just have to stand in awe of that level of courage. I can’t imagine what it must take to keep going when you know full well there are people who are willing to stop at nothing to hurt you and — worse yet — your family.

    And I agree with c’lady: America’s role in these areas has often
    been far from noble. When the rest of the world takes note of things like this and of Dubya’s behavior in the ME, is it any wonder that so many fear and distrust us?

    Thanks for introducing us to the “Butterflies”!

    • SueInCa says:

      You are welcome BFF. I may have another story coming up. PBS Independent Lens is doing a story next week called, Blessed is the Match about a young woman who was safe in Israel but went to Germany to try to free others. I won’t tell you the ending. I am reading the book by Julia Alvarez and it pretty closely follows the movie I saw. I also am going to order the other movie, Tropico de Sangre and a book that Cyrano told me about(see below) and The Feast of the Goat by Mario Vargas Llosa. I have them all put aside on Amazon.

  4. SallyT says:

    Sherlock, I read your very educational article. I knew of these ladies but not all the details. I will not try to add anything in addition to your post except to say, I bet Monsanto was involved somehow. 😉

    Dr. Watson is on call.

    • SueInCa says:

      Watson, Now you got me on the Monsanto trail. I was interested but did not follow the story that closely, now I am signing petitions and posting on FB. I just posted a petition about the super worm and compared Monsanto to Dow Chemical in Bhopal lol. Damn you Watson :-)

  5. choicelady says:

    Oh wow, Sue, this is stunning. I vaguely recall hearing about the murder, some years AFTER the fact, but really knew none of the details and thus none of the courage.

    I have found, over the years, the degree of brutality in Central and South America that we supported until recently to be beyond comprehension. We trained so many of the warlord thugs in the School of the Americas, teaching them the very techniques used by the Gestapo so that, in the interests of “freedom” (anti-communist dictators) they could repress all manner of reforms that would benefit ordinary people. From daSilva in Brazil to Pinochet in Chile to Rios Montt in Guatamala we have consistently been on the side of repressive and brutal dictators.

    Friends of mine were victims. One, a U.S. Methodist minister, was arrested and tortured in Brazil, another blown up in the car with his wife and Orlando Letelier, both of whom died in front of him. I am terrified of that set of policies returning since the forces behind such actions were and are still alive and well in our own government, in the CIA and other agencies. It is one of many reasons that Obama is hated by the Right for his massive change in policy. The most powerful forces behine the scenes are those of The Family who have paid off these agents of repression and who have used their US based power to enlist the CIA in continuing the violence and brutality.

    In Latin America one of the factors behind the good has been the Catholic Church, the worker priests who allied with the repressed. They as well have been killed and tortured. So much for respecting “religion”. In Guatamala and many other nations, the Dominionists, deeply wedded to the “Ryan” notions of capitalism triumphant never mind faith values, are vying to win the people away from the Church, and even John Paul chastized his own priests for their ‘disrespect’ of authority telling them to provide charity NOT fight for justice. One hopes -- HOPES -- that Francis will be different, but there is a rumor he turned people over to the dictators in Argentina, contributing to the numbers of “the disaapeareds”. Don’t know if it’s true, but it’s very disturbing to think he was no different.

    These four women represent the face of those who, from time immemorial, risked everything to stand for their cause of justice. Their story is powerful, and it is very little known even with the film. Thank you for giving shape, form, and face to who they were and are.

    Oh that we should have such courage!

    • SueInCa says:

      CL

      These are the types of stories I want to tell. Like you, I had no real understanding of the background of the Dominican Republic but in the space of a week, learned quite a bit. There has been different influences, similar to Haiti which makes sense since they share the Island. I know about our CIA and the Right and their interference in Latin America but the details are sometimes gained from a fictionalized account such as the movie I watched. IMHO the movie was not far off from what actually happened. I am now reading the book and will read some of the others I encountered in this research.

  6. cyrano1 says:

    Sue in CA: Thanks for your fascinating article! The DR is so interesting, filled with a history and culture even crazier, more brutal, than ours on the US mainland.

    Pulitzer prize winner Junot Diaz (a native of the DR) is one of my very favorite authors, and his powerful 2007 book, “The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao” is one of my all time favorites and it’s stuck with me years later. It’s an absolute must-read.

    He’s an activist on immigration reform and his most recent interview took place a few days ago with Colbert.

    http://www.colbertnation.com/the-colbert-report-videos/424718/march-25-2013/junot-diaz

    • SueInCa says:

      Cyrano
      Thanks I will look up that book and will watch the interview with Colbert. Thanks for the info. I have an interest in the Latin Americas but had never really delved deep into each country’s history. I learned a lot in the week I took to write this article up.

      I do know the Family and Dominionists have entrenched themselves in there for political gain and to further expand their twisted view of Christianity. I think the closest we come is the Revolutionary War, The Civil War, the fight for Unions, the fight for women’s rights and the civil rights actions. Come to think of it, that is quite a bit for a “civilized” society.


Leave your Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.


Back to top
PlanetPOV Tweets
Ongoing Stories
Features